First time thanks to Too Good To Go app. Had 2 slices of thin crust pizza and a garlic knot. The garlic knot was soft and delicious. The pizza slices were pepperoni and spinach - both were good. The cheese was good and they are thin crust which had the perfect crunchiness. Unfortunately the garlic knot didn't make it home since it went inside while driving... The prices are very affordable, although I expected it to be expensive. It's a small shop in the Mission Gorge area near where In N Out is (the adjacent plaza). I would like to try more pizza slices again.

Came as a party of 2 on a Friday at 6:30 PM. This pizza place is one of my favorite finds of 2024. I've never been to New York, but I believe I know what good pizza tastes like and this is it! I can't rave about this place enough. Parking: There's a large parking lot, but it can fill up quickly, especially during busy hours. Be prepared to circle for a spot if you arrive during peak times. Ambience: The space is small, clean, and primarily designed for carryout or takeout, with just two tables inside. Service: Quick, efficient, and the owner provides amazing hospitality. You feel welcomed from the moment you walk in. This place is a local hidden gem. Food: $10 Combo - A fantastic deal that contains two ginormous slices of pizza and a drink for just $10. The crusts for all pizzas are light, thin, and crispy. BBQ Chicken Pizza - 9/10: This pizza was packed with flavor, featuring tender chicken, tangy BBQ sauce, red onions, and a hint of cilantro. The balance of savory and sweet was spot on. Brooklyn Bridge's Pizza - 8.5/10: A hearty, flavorful option with pepperoni, meatball, and sausage. Grand Pa's Pizza - 8/10: A delicious combination of ricotta, pizza sauce, and meatball. The ricotta added a nice creaminess. Summary: The pizza is absolutely top-notch, with giant slices and a perfectly crispy crust that transports you straight to New York. This place is a must-visit, I dream about the next time I get to eat here.

Bbq chicken pizza is amazing good it's so good have eaten it for 3 days in a row lol.

The best pizza in San Diego by far. I've tried many pizza places looking for the New York slice. This is the one I will come back to.

This is my first time ordering from here. I ordered an 18in Cheese pizza along with bbq wings. Both were absolutely delicious.

This Brooklyn pizzeria is hands down the real deal! From the moment I walked in, I knew I was in for something special. The classic New York pizza vibes are all here--thin, crispy crust with just the right amount of chew, topped with the freshest ingredients. Each slice is perfection! The sauce is flavorful and tangy, and the cheese is perfectly melted with that satisfying stretch. The ambiance is cozy and authentic, with that old-school Brooklyn charm. Whether you're grabbing a quick slice or sitting down for a whole pie, the service is fast and friendly. If you're craving true Brooklyn-style pizza, this spot delivers every time. Five stars, no doubt!

We order from Brooklyn Pizzeria at least once a week. We had out of town guests last weekend from Texas and LA and had the party catered by an outside vendor for the adults and ordered a bunch of pizzas from Brooklyn for the kids. Well both the adults and kids were all over this pizza. While they enjoyed the other catering vendor too, everyone could not stop raving about the pizza. Owner is awesome and even called and followed up to see how everything was. Very happy with service and food!

Great pizza with a nice crust. I do wish they offered some lunch specials. They offer other items on the menu if you didn't come in for a slice of the premade pizzas they had on display. Only came for a quick slice to go. Facility does not appear to have customer restroom if needed as shop is very small with limited seating.

So good! Will be coming back! There was quite a bit of options to choose from! Joseph was also very nice as well!